Marking.1: Intro - Covenant : Information good, but ultimately limited to space. Showing tactical analysis, but not expansive of an argument encompasing all possiblities. Also failing to define exactly WHAT the covenant is. It is something made of lots of different species, but what are it's goals and values that make it the covenant? There is more then obliteration to win a war.
- Goa'uld : To a very similar degree as the covenant debater, but you briefly touch upon ground forces. I believe you may have just been following the prophets suite in your introduction, hidden countering his points making your own the same.
Introduction notes overall: Both had good information, but lacked in some parts. Structure of the introduction was good though and in future could be a little more flowing and less robotic.
2: Arguments/main body : Covenant : High grades of information, but once again focusing solely on fleet engadgements, and lacking flow/real structure.
Goa'uld : Not so wide a range of information as the covenant, but a better presented argument.
3: Ability to counter : Covenant : Exceedingly well.
Goa'uld : Not an amazing ability.
4: answering public questions : Covenant : Once again, exceedingly high.
Goa'uld - Non displayed, but no opportunities presented themselves.
Penalties : false/mis information : Covenant:
1. "and before that a light cruiser obliterated the planets population in a matter of hours." - no according to halo wiki using a description of the battle of harvest, the covenant cruiser landed troops and attacked the suburbs before the populance were evacuated and the city militia began attacking the covenant. Then the cruiser was disabled using a mass driver a "Primitive" version of a MAC, allowing plenty of the populance to escape in an orbital station and then nearly a quatre of a million to escape. The entire planets populace was then eradicated, some 3million humans, by the glassing of the planet done so by a larger covenant cruiser.
2. "As stated above Covenant orbital cities can survive and impact with a moon" That was applied to the Heirophant, there is nothing to suggest that it goes for any others if possibly not all covenant orbital space stations.
http://halo.wikia.com/wiki/Battle_of_Harvest 3. "Covenant Ground Forces use shielded as defenses rending the Goa'uld ability to blast through defenses inoperable" - I point out the halo games, basic human guns, and grenades (shotguns etc) and even covenant PLASMA weaponry is capable of easily enough breaking covenant personal shielding.
Goa'uld :
1. "and weak regular plasma" - Plasma is the same for every race. It is a state of being, like a solid, liquid, gas. It can be heated more, or fired faster.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plasma_%28physics%29Marks:
1 (/20): Cov - 15, Goa'uld - 13
2 (/20): Cov - 14, Goa'uld - 12
3 (/15): Cov - 15, Goa'uld - 7
4 (/15): Cov - 15, Goa'uld - 7
and finally for structure/presentation or arguments: (/30) Cov - 13 Goa'uld - 14.
Totals : Cov - 72, Goa'uld - 54
combined with tom - Cov - 145/200 = 73 (70)% Goa'uld - 112/200 = 56 (55)%
*-1% for each penalty.
Cov grade = B, Goa'uld = D.
Final notes: I think that in this situation, it was the first debate to set off and it shows. For the interest of both participants id say apady, get a bit more detailed, and Prophet too much knowledge can sometimes be an achillies heel.
I finally add that the Covenants super lasers did exhaust the power of the cruisers on all but the largest of vessels, and that the goa'uld shields are penetrable by pin point kinetic energy (ie. darts, or needler guns...). In the end though id say this debate went to the covenant without the need to clarify using marks.
None the less. You have been graded.