StarGateWars Forums

cause of the dynamic Cap update i think this is a must now

there be too much naq flying around and broker will not cut it

how would you know who took out how much naq and how much you can take out?

I think this idea is brilliant and hopefully will happen.

zirtux wrote:how would you know who took out how much naq and how much you can take out?

I supose the alliance leader would be the one who you would need to send a naq request too and if accepted, the naq would go straight into your bank and every alliance member would get a message saying, a member from your alliance, (Name) has had the naq request accepted and (Naq amount) as been deposited to there bank.

I supose even a message could be sent out to all when ever someone makes a request so that other members can say no if its a problem.

Like I said before, this is a brill idea, its just a shame its taking so long to get the update hope there will be one

This is an excellent idea. Has it ever been considering for the alliance to be able to hold ATs in their bank as well?

Instead of bank, it could called the alliance "War Chest"

holding ATs would quite easily foster multies... single players having huge alliances to get free ATs... so bad idea...

i think the withdrawals should go through the leader and the 2IC so say i want to deposit naq the naq goes into the bank and under where i deposited the naq is a link to a alliance bank history shows who has been withdrawing and depositing.
and say i want to take out the naq i just put in id have to put in a request for the naq. If you where the alliance leader or 2IC there would be a link ( under history) that said withdraw requests (then a number) they would click on the withdraw requests button and there would be a list of all the withdraw requests that havent been dealt with and it would say how much naq my name and it would have 2 buttons accept or deny.

another way we coudl do that i dont think is very promising is you having to have a certain number of votes from while alliance same set up with buttons just having to have votes say you need 25% of your alliance to get the naq out

-rube

_Rube_Dragon_ wrote:i think the withdrawals should go through the leader and the 2IC so say i want to deposit naq the naq goes into the bank and under where i deposited the naq is a link to a alliance bank history shows who has been withdrawing and depositing.

maybe have this, with one variation... ability for leader to set more to be able to withdraw...

also, there should be a certain limit on how large portion someone can withdraw at once, so that all isnt withdrawn by one, then that one leaves alliance...

EDIT:
maybe have up to say 33% removable at any time, for larger, 50% of alliance has to agree first... or leader(s) have to agree...

that kinda makes it harder for a person to acquire their hard earned naq but i understand why something of the sort should be put in place because dont want anyone running away with all the naq.

Simple, make the leader or 2IC approve the withdrawal. I have seen this work in another game which a few SGW players play, where there is a 6% tax for deposits and withdrawals can only be approved by the alliance leader and 2IC. I am surprised that with all this support it still hasn't been implemented.

i dont think that 6% is a big diffrence from the 5% taken normally peopel need to use their bankes before they use the allience bank. so as many of us have suggested make it more around 10%-15% which i think is a good ammount becasue the alleicne banks are far bigger and have more storage and are further away form your realm maning it costs more to safely move it from your realm to the alliance bank.
and are you talking about realm battles?

10-15 % of your income would go into the alliance bank EVERY turn... Or the leader would be able to change the tax from 0% to 15 %, no tax at deposit, tax AT every turn

hmm that seems a bit to much like chaos but i love the idea and how it keeps a section of your incoe safe along withthe % that is taken out of your income woudl you also be able to deposit naq and withdral that woudl be nice

Totally in favour of alliance bank.
Although we can manage quite well too.. it would just ease the whole thing.
Besides, our banks aren't large enough atm to hold the dough.

i love the idea of the alliance bank, it would help all alliances out aswell with the smaller and bigger players. some people would abuse the privilege of it though, by making an alliance and just using the alliance bank as their normal bank. so something should definately schemed up their to stop abusers.

i think a player requirement: you need 5+ players in order to use the alliance bank, 4- players in the alliance wouldnt really be called an alliance, it would be more like a group.

secret unknown dude wrote:i love the idea of the alliance bank, it would help all alliances out aswell with the smaller and bigger players. some people would abuse the privilege of it though, by making an alliance and just using the alliance bank as their normal bank. so something should definately schemed up their to stop abusers.

i think a player requirement: you need 5+ players in order to use the alliance bank, 4- players in the alliance wouldnt really be called an alliance, it would be more like a group.

in essence, the above means that alliance has to be ranked on the attack/alliance pages? (requirement for that, we seem to remember is 5 members)