StarGateWars Forums

Ok Jim.


What is your specific suggestion? Move the Council to an external forum?

from our (limited) understanding, the alliances allowed in are any alliance/empire that wants to get in...

What would be the point in having a section or such for an alliance that doesn't want it?

look every alliance who want sin is in of crouse if you have suggestions pass them on to your representative and they will bring it up if you dont have an alliance they just send JT or some in the GC a PM for them to bring it up. did you ever go to school. lol
As ling as your point get across then who cares.

you guys are fighting over some people stepping up to sort the Shizz storm we have on our hands.

please people.

sam

~Deuce~ wrote:look every alliance who want sin is in of crouse if you have suggestions pass them on to your representative and they will bring it up if you dont have an alliance they just send JT or some in the GC a PM for them to bring it up. did you ever go to school. lol
As ling as your point get across then who cares.

you guys are fighting over some people stepping up to sort the Shizz storm we have on our hands.

please people.

sam

the point is, it should be public for all to see, since we are all in this Galactic Council with only a few representatives, everyone should be allowed to see what goes on.

thats the only issue i have with it, other than that its good to go, id like to see how this pans out just like the next guy, and id love it to work.

having it public might not be a bad idea... but since we're not part of it, we're not going to meddle with it...

it is not unusual for hidden sections with a purpose of the level this one has, to survive for a while hidden, then die slowly... thats what happened with the respect group...

As I already said, Rocky. That's a decision the Council itself has to reach.

Lets ask this question..why was there no complaining about it beforehand in the initial GC thread? and why were these concerns not taken up with your alliance leader that represents you and why oh why is there a post all of a sudden when someone (not mentioning names) makes the post? Bias anyone?

Jim wrote:For the most part im playing devils advocate here, but i think the main issue is Game Vs Forum.
This council only has select alliances in it, and these select alliances are allowed on the forums to a secret section. The forum therefore is supporting these alliances more than any other.

This council only has select alliances in it true, but the guidelines to become a select alliance are posted. Play devils advocate, I think the game needs help right about now not hinderance.

we'd say this thread is the public version of the similar thread you have in the galactic council section...

Jedi~Tank wrote:Lets ask this question..why was there no complaining about it beforehand in the initial GC thread? and why were these concerns not taken up with your alliance leader that represents you and why oh why is there a post all of a sudden when someone (not mentioning names) makes the post? Bias anyone?

*i mentioned it in the initial thread as well actually
*my alliance leaders aren't in the GC group yet
*its only mentioned now because no one ever mentioned how this is going to work until very recently, and tbh that's not even the point.
also what has bias got to do with anything?

There is nothing more to even talk about, Deni said it twice, the section was just made today ..... no one has any idea how it's going to function. I would assume there will be a public topic, or a public (read-only) sub-section. Who knows!

Look, im not trying to argue about the way the GC is run, if its going to function well, who should be allowed in it blah blah blah.

Just asking, when has the forum ever endorsed particular alliances or alliance groups in such a way? If the GC was made up of intelligent people that were selected because of personal merit then sure, but they are selected by alliance. The GC is therefore alliance based.

The guidelines are clear in the original Gatewars Galactic Council post.

Ss maybe you should read what i posted and then reply again.

So do Lone Wolfs have to put up with the suggestions forum that never gets looked at by Jason?