Page 1 of 2
Reporting posts
Posted: Sun Mar 09, 2008 10:34 am
by geisha
When reporting a post, shouldn't I get a feedback? I just reported one and all I got was the confirmation that my report was closed and that's it. No response by the mod who closed it. I was simply ignored.
Re: Reporting posts
Posted: Sun Mar 09, 2008 10:42 am
by GeneralChaos
I have always gotten feedback on reported posts. Does the post warrent feedback, like if it was just a black market post, it may not require feedback, just a thought.
Re: Reporting posts
Posted: Sun Mar 09, 2008 10:44 am
by geisha
it was about biased moderating so it actually doesn't surprise me that I never got feedback
Re: Reporting posts
Posted: Sun Mar 09, 2008 10:46 am
by GeneralChaos
I don't think there is as much of that these days, i find most ( not all ) of the mods now are fairly even, maybe your report just got picked up by someone who has issues with you, i would PM smoosh im sure he can look into it more if you feel you where unfairly treated.
Re: Reporting posts
Posted: Sun Mar 09, 2008 10:47 am
by Teal'auc of the Void
Geisha, seriously, stop begging for attention.
I locked the topic because it was full of insults and slander. And just because you always need to have a go at me, that's not my problem. I don't give a damn what people think of TLE, I personally am not fan of them either, so there goes even your 'bias' part...
Seriously, stop testing the moderators.
Teal'auc
Re: Reporting posts
Posted: Sun Mar 09, 2008 10:48 am
by GeneralChaos
I guess you can call that your feedback
Re: Reporting posts
Posted: Sun Mar 09, 2008 10:54 am
by geisha
Teal'auc of the Tok'ra wrote:Geisha, seriously, stop begging for attention.
I locked the topic because it was full of insults and slander. And just because you always need to have a go at me, that's not my problem. I don't give a damn what people think of TLE, I personally am not fan of them either, so there goes even your 'bias' part...
Seriously, stop testing the moderators.
Teal'auc
umm, if I remember correctly all I said was (didn't save the report so I have to retype it):
This is a perfect example of censoring topics just because a moderator doesn't agree with their content. While I personally don't agree with what the topic author says, I still don't think it is against the rules. He is stating his opinion about an alliance based on their ingame actions and forum posts. Isn't that a part of what these forums are all about? Hell, there even was the "official I hate Omega thread" on the forums for months. It's a war game after all. Nothing wrong with that.
I don't see any personal insults or rule violation in the initial post. To be fair, I haven't read all posts but even if they contained rule violations, shouldn't they just have been modded instead of locking the whole thread?
I do not see how I was having a go at you there. Sorry but you are not that important to me. I am just always concerned about over-moderation on these boards and I do speak up when I see it happening.
Re: Reporting posts
Posted: Sun Mar 09, 2008 10:56 am
by Teal'auc of the Void
Geisha, read the topic carefully... it was full of slander and people were basically flaming each other. They made new topic, and as long as people are able to discuss without insults, nobody will have problem with that topic staying there. But what's too much that's too much... as was the last topic about TLE.
Teal'auc
Re: Reporting posts
Posted: Sun Mar 09, 2008 11:02 am
by geisha
I just think it is rather poor to lock topics completely instead of modding the posts that have to be modded.
The forums have gotten a lot better since Smoosh is in charge but there used to be a time when moderators thought "moderator" is another word for "locking machine". I just don't want those times to come back.
Also, you could have just responded to my report instead of closing it and ignoring me. Just a thought. Being a mod isn't all about clicking buttons
Re: Reporting posts
Posted: Sun Mar 09, 2008 11:06 am
by Teal'auc of the Void
geisha wrote:I just think it is rather poor to lock topics completely instead of modding the posts that have to be modded.
The forums have gotten a lot better since Smoosh is in charge but there used to be a time when moderators thought "moderator" is another word for "locking machine". I just don't want those times to come back.
Also, you could have just responded to my report instead of closing it and ignoring me. Just a thought. Being a mod isn't all about clicking buttons
Yah, sorry, I could've respond to the report. That's my bad.
However, modding the topic is a bit pointless, seeing we have another one now in place. Hopefully cleaner one.
Teal'auc
Re: Reporting posts
Posted: Sun Mar 09, 2008 11:10 am
by Zeratul
modding a topic is far too often not enough to stop the behavior trend of the posters...
Re: Reporting posts
Posted: Sun Mar 09, 2008 11:14 am
by geisha
Zeratul wrote:modding a topic is far too often not enough to stop the behavior trend of the posters...
But you can at least try, can't you? I always thought locking should be the last option but maybe that's just me.
Anyway, were are going off topic here. My question in this thread was whether forum users should get feedback for reporting posts or not. I'm just asking because if ignoring reports is a common thing, then I won't bother reporting posts in future.
Re: Reporting posts
Posted: Sun Mar 09, 2008 11:16 am
by Teal'auc of the Void
geisha wrote:Zeratul wrote:modding a topic is far too often not enough to stop the behavior trend of the posters...
But you can at least try, can't you? I always thought locking should be the last option but maybe that's just me.
Anyway, were are going off topic here. My question in this thread was whether forum users should get feedback for reporting posts or not. I'm just asking because if ignoring reports is a common thing, then I won't bother reporting posts in future.
It is not. reports are dealt with... if they are valid. Thanks goodness, people rarely misuse report function these days. I hope that answers your question.
Teal'auc
Re: Reporting posts
Posted: Sun Mar 09, 2008 11:25 am
by geisha
All reports are valid as long as the reporter states why he is reporting a post...
So I read your reply here as "reports will be responded to if the moderator who is the first one to read them agrees with them, if the moderator doesn't agree, then they will just get closed without a comment or explanation"?
Re: Reporting posts
Posted: Sun Mar 09, 2008 11:28 am
by Teal'auc of the Void
geisha wrote:All reports are valid as long as the reporter states why he is reporting a post...
So I read your reply here as "reports will be responded to if the moderator who is the first one to read them agrees with them, if the moderator doesn't agree, then they will just get closed without a comment or explanation"?
It's not agreeing or disagreeing. Also, me closing your report was a mistake, I believe I stated that and apologized few posts ahead.
Teal'auc