StarGateWars Forums

Since a topic got moved from General to the Dump with the explanation

FreeSpirit wrote:Ingame politics should be handeled ingame. Moved to the dupm

I am rather confused what actually belongs in General as apparently "ingame politics" are not "general ingame discussion" anymore. Can please someone enlighten me. Thank you

Haha, the vast majority of discussion which takes place in this section is related, at least in some way, to in-game politics. Remove that from the equation and you'll be left with a dozen happy birthday threads and 'lol whats ur strike" polls.

as Mordack says...actually thats the most interesting part of this forum for me...majority of other threads imo dont belong to SGW general...


Like save the whales and similar threads...







Blue

lol how is it even ingame politics...it's more of a rant 'i want my repayment'....
i mean i suppose a pm doesn't work anymore so we just publish every bump on the road we have on our SGW career on a forum for all the rest to 'gaze' upon...

The topic had nothing to do with the general politics of sgw its was a banter over repayment by a broken nap attack. This does not belong in sgw general but should be sorted out between the diplo's of each alliance. I dont know how DDE runs their show but the majorty of sgw does it that way.

FreeSpirit wrote:The topic had nothing to do with the general politics of sgw its was a banter over repayment by a broken nap attack. This does not belong in sgw general but should be sorted out between the diplo's of each alliance. I dont know how DDE runs their show but the majorty of sgw does it that way.

So your saying you know how the vast majority runs their alliance . But you dont know squat about the #1 ranked alliance? Seems your paying attention to the wrong allliances if you ask me.

I am saying that the majorty does and that they cant have interest for a napbreach and the repayments of it. OW on that note let me move this to forum issues

killtacular wrote:

FreeSpirit wrote:The topic had nothing to do with the general politics of sgw its was a banter over repayment by a broken nap attack. This does not belong in sgw general but should be sorted out between the diplo's of each alliance. I dont know how DDE runs their show but the majorty of sgw does it that way.

So your saying you know how the vast majority runs their alliance . But you dont know squat about the #1 ranked alliance? Seems your paying attention to the wrong allliances if you ask me.

why would he care about 44 members ? look, only on alliance ranking first page, there is 871 players in top 30 alliances... DDE is around 5% of first page, nothing less, nothing more. Being in the first ranked alliance doesnt change your status. It's only showing the the galaxy that u love to build high stats.

FreeSpirit wrote:The topic had nothing to do with the general politics of sgw its was a banter over repayment by a broken nap attack. This does not belong in sgw general but should be sorted out between the diplo's of each alliance. I dont know how DDE runs their show but the majorty of sgw does it that way.

FreeSpirit wrote:Ingame politics should be handeled ingame. Moved to the dupm

conterdiction???

FreeSpirit wrote:I am saying that the majorty does and that they cant have interest for a napbreach and the repayments of it. OW on that note let me move this to forum issues

StarGateWars General
Forum for all general ingame discussion.

k...

well we wouldn't want a negative topic about TJP now would we? only negative topics about FUALL breaking naps are allowed, not about the order breaking naps...

FreeSpirit wrote:The topic had nothing to do with the general politics of sgw its was a banter over repayment by a broken nap attack. This does not belong in sgw general but should be sorted out between the diplo's of each alliance. I dont know how DDE runs their show but the majorty of sgw does it that way.

This topic has nothing to do with any breaking of NAPs or repayments due, but what belongs in General or not. As it stands now posts about broken NAPs are not worthy of General. Would that have changed if there was a poll attached asking if the General public trusts the alliance who broke the NAP? If we cannot inform the general public that a NAP has been broken in General, what is the right forum section to do it? Surely the GC if it leads to war, but what if does not?


On a side note: How the majority "runs their show" does not usually mean they are right. After all DDE has been here for a while so maybe we run our show slightly better then the majority. After all we are the no 1 alliance, aren't we?


I also would like to ask you to use your mod colours. Makes it easier for all involved to separate the player from the mod as this separation has not been visible lately. Thank you.

deni wrote:

FreeSpirit wrote:The topic had nothing to do with the general politics of sgw its was a banter over repayment by a broken nap attack. This does not belong in sgw general but should be sorted out between the diplo's of each alliance. I dont know how DDE runs their show but the majorty of sgw does it that way.

This topic has nothing to do with any breaking of NAPs or repayments due, but what belongs in General or not. As it stands now posts about broken NAPs are not worthy of General. Would that have changed if there was a poll attached asking if the General public trusts the alliance who broke the NAP? If we cannot inform the general public that a NAP has been broken in General, what is the right forum section to do it? Surely the GC if it leads to war, but what if does not?


On a side note: How the majority "runs their show" does not usually mean they are right. After all DDE has been here for a while so maybe we run our show slightly better then the majority. After all we are the no 1 alliance, aren't we?


I also would like to ask you to use your mod colours. Makes it easier for all involved to separate the player from the mod as this separation has not been visible lately. Thank you.

Hear, hear.

Sorry FS, but they're right..

deni wrote:

FreeSpirit wrote:The topic had nothing to do with the general politics of sgw its was a banter over repayment by a broken nap attack. This does not belong in sgw general but should be sorted out between the diplo's of each alliance. I dont know how DDE runs their show but the majorty of sgw does it that way.

This topic has nothing to do with any breaking of NAPs or repayments due, but what belongs in General or not. As it stands now posts about broken NAPs are not worthy of General. Would that have changed if there was a poll attached asking if the General public trusts the alliance who broke the NAP? If we cannot inform the general public that a NAP has been broken in General, what is the right forum section to do it? Surely the GC if it leads to war, but what if does not?

The topic was made by MFC demanding repayments. NAP breaches are not sgw general issues. If every alliance would post their nap breaches here it would be considered yes. Even attaching a poll to it woudnt change the subject

deni wrote:On a side note: How the majority "runs their show" does not usually mean they are right. After all DDE has been here for a while so maybe we run our show slightly better then the majority. After all we are the no 1 alliance, aren't we?

You know aswell as I that rank 1 means nothing in this game. Every alliance runs their show as they wish as they are free to do so. However 99% of the alliances ingame dont go posting broken naps on the sgw forum and esspecially not claiming rpeyments they leave it up for the diplomats in the alliance to solve as thats the reasson they are appointed as diplomats.

deni wrote:I also would like to ask you to use your mod colours. Makes it easier for all involved to separate the player from the mod as this separation has not been visible lately. Thank you.

I use my modcolor when it is followed my a mod action. Or when i make a statement as a mad. When you contact me about an issue i respond the way i see fit.

FreeSpirit wrote:I am saying that the majorty does and that they cant have interest for a napbreach and the repayments of it. OW on that note let me move this to forum issues

Would that not warrant your mod colour?

Yes it would i didnt notice i didnt color it. Sorry wont happen next time. Once again on the issue of the topic.

These sorts of threads have always been a bit of a grey line as while they relate to stargatewars, it differs from the abstract discussions and wide announcements the forum is generally used for.

This is a very specific incident aimed at a very specific target and as such, should be adressed to that target. It was not a discussion, debate, public announcement or even a talk on an abstracted set of ideas or ingame mechanics.

It was a personal and private matter which are best off delt with in the more appropiate communication mediums. That is using the ingame private messaging system or instant messagers like MSN. If we encouraged and did not moderate this sort of occurance, it would essentially open the flood gates for turning the general forums into a charade for shame campaigns and threads which have little or no relevence to the readers.

As such we have to be careful not to endorse certain behaviour in order to encourage a more positive and relevent usage of the General forums.