Page 1 of 2
Fatal error at Best Alliance Signature 2008 voting topic
Posted: Tue Feb 03, 2009 8:54 am
by AXYS
Semper wrote:There are six nominations for this category because of a draw for third place.
Valid (>50 postcount) Best Alliance Signature 2008 Nominations:1st - DDE: I. I. I. I. I. I. I. I. I. (9)
2nd - EPA: I. I. I. I. I. (5)
3rd draw - Alpha:
I. I. I. I. (4)
3rd draw - Forgotten Serenity:
I. I. I. I. (4)
3rd draw - Hungarian Unity: AXYS, Colos, kvarga, Kondasz (4)3rd draw - Radical Minority:
I. I. I. I. (4)
4th - The Collective: I. I. I. Already voided... (3)All of
these nominations for HU were already counted in by MajorLeeHurts.
So,
Hungarian Unity SIG was left out in the cold
and The Collective SIG was included without reason.
Great job, Semper.
Pardon?
edit1:
added names for right nominationsedit2:
I'm not contesting the count.
I'm contesting being left out of the voting.edit3:
The fourth valid The Collective nomination is missing.
TC should not have been forwarded to voting.
Re: Negligence/cheating at Best Alliance Signature 2008 voting
Posted: Tue Feb 03, 2009 11:42 am
by _willie_
AXYS wrote:Semper wrote:There are six nominations for this category because of a draw for third place.
Valid (>50 postcount) Best Alliance Signature 2008 Nominations:1st - DDE: I. I. I. I. I. I. I. I. I. (9)
2nd - EPA: I. I. I. I. I. (5)
3rd draw - Alpha:
I. I. I. I. (4)
3rd draw - Forgotten Serenity:
I. I. I. I. (4)
3rd draw - Hungarian Unity: 1.., 2.., 3.., 4.. (4)3rd draw - Radical Minority:
I. I. I. I. (4)
4th - The Collective: I. I. I. Already voided... (3)All of
these nominations for HU were counted by MajorLeeHurts.
So,
Hungarian Unity SIG was left out in the cold without reason.
Great job, Semper.
Pardon?
no it was counted rightly most of the people have less then 50 post there for were not counted.
Re: Negligence/cheating at Best Alliance Signature 2008 voting
Posted: Tue Feb 03, 2009 11:51 am
by AXYS
Check links again...
And.. I've said all of the
4 HU nominations were COUNTED by MajorLeeHurts.
Counted means MLH wrote
counted into post, and inserted editing comment "counting noms".
I'm NOT talking about the voided nominations.
Don't make me say again.
AXYS wrote:Valid (>50 postcount) Best Alliance Signature 2008 Nominations
Re: Negligence/cheating at Best Alliance Signature 2008 voting
Posted: Tue Feb 03, 2009 11:59 am
by buck
I do not follow.
At least one of thos who voted for your hungarian sig was not counted. It was not counted because the account was under 50 posts, to avoid cheating. Any post that was voided has been voided.
You do not make any sense, Explain.
Re: Negligence/cheating at Best Alliance Signature 2008 voting
Posted: Tue Feb 03, 2009 12:01 pm
by AXYS
buck wrote:I do not follow.
At least one of thos who voted for your hungarian sig was not counted. It was not counted because the account was under 50 posts, to avoid cheating. Any post that was voided has been voided.
You do not make any sense, Explain.
Give time to your browser for positioning to right posts all I can say.
Re: Negligence/cheating at Best Alliance Signature 2008 voting
Posted: Tue Feb 03, 2009 12:08 pm
by buck
So it is.
SEMPERRRR.
Re: Negligence/cheating at Best Alliance Signature 2008 voting
Posted: Tue Feb 03, 2009 12:08 pm
by Noobert
Adaren
oath-bound to be respectful
Joined: Sun Dec 30, 2007 12:39 pm
Posts: 32
Voided.
Gent
Joined: Thu May 01, 2008 11:43 am
Posts: 2
Alliance: Hungarian Command
Race: Ancient
ID: 1920288
Voided.
Re: Negligence/cheating at Best Alliance Signature 2008 voting
Posted: Tue Feb 03, 2009 12:12 pm
by AXYS
Noobert wrote:Adaren
oath-bound to be respectful
Joined: Sun Dec 30, 2007 12:39 pm
Posts: 32
Voided.
Gent
Joined: Thu May 01, 2008 11:43 am
Posts: 2
Alliance: Hungarian Command
Race: Ancient
ID: 1920288
Voided.
AXYS wrote:Give time to your browser for positioning to right posts all I can say.
The owner of the right posts are AXYS, Colos, kvarga and Kondasz.
Re: Negligence/cheating at Best Alliance Signature 2008 voting
Posted: Tue Feb 03, 2009 12:13 pm
by Juliette
AXYS wrote:Give time to your browser for positioning to right posts all I can say.
The owner of the right post are AXYS, Colos, kvarga and Kondasz.
Confirmed.
Re: Negligence/cheating at Best Alliance Signature 2008 voting
Posted: Tue Feb 03, 2009 12:15 pm
by Noobert
Odd. It didn't reposition the first time. Second time it did.
Seems there are four..
Re: Negligence/cheating at Best Alliance Signature 2008 voting
Posted: Tue Feb 03, 2009 12:19 pm
by Caprila
MajorleeHurts and myself, both counted through the votes when nominations were completed. I have just been through the topic, and recounted.
My First Count wrote:THE DARK DOMINIUM 10
Alpha 5
EPA 5
Forgotten Serenity 4
Hungarian Unity 4
Second Count wrote:DDE 10
Alpha 5
EPA 4
Forgotten Serenity 4
Hungarian Unity 4
As you can see, it was not a matter of discounting HU votes, but an invisibile additional EPA vote that changed.
No I did not do this purposefully, it was purely accidental, I assure you. I apologise to you for the confusion, and as soon as Semper comes on, I'll get him to sort this out
One point though, seems a little OTT to make a topic about cheating mods over my maths skills
Re: Negligence/cheating at Best Alliance Signature 2008 voting
Posted: Tue Feb 03, 2009 12:25 pm
by Juliette
Caprila wrote:MajorleeHurts and myself, both counted through the votes when nominations were completed. I have just been through the topic, and recounted.
My First Count wrote:THE DARK DOMINIUM 10
Alpha 5
EPA 5
Forgotten Serenity 4
Hungarian Unity 4
Second Count wrote:DDE 10
Alpha 5
EPA 4
Forgotten Serenity 4
Hungarian Unity 4
As you can see, it was not a matter of discounting HU votes, but an invisibile additional EPA vote that changed.
No I did not do this purposefully, it was purely accidental, I assure you. I apologise to you for the confusion, and as soon as Semper comes on, I'll get him to sort this out
One point though, seems a little OTT to make a topic about cheating mods over my maths skills
AXYS wrote:edit2:
I'm not contesting the count.
I'm contesting being left out of the voting.
Re: Negligence/cheating at Best Alliance Signature 2008 voting
Posted: Tue Feb 03, 2009 12:27 pm
by AXYS
Caprila wrote:As you can see, it was not a matter of discounting HU votes, but an invisibile additional EPA vote that changed.
I know
Robe posted into the locked topic, but it's irrelevant in HU's case
Re: Negligence/cheating at Best Alliance Signature 2008 voting
Posted: Tue Feb 03, 2009 12:31 pm
by Caprila
@Universe.
Only the top 3 in each category went through to voting. Hence the additional EPA vote changed the alliances.
DDE, Alpha, EPA - > should have been - > DDE, Alpha, EPA, FS, HU
That is why HU was left out of the vote (and FS too) and it what I was explaining.
Re: Negligence/cheating at Best Alliance Signature 2008 voting
Posted: Tue Feb 03, 2009 12:36 pm
by AXYS
Nope, HU is "in", either way with four noms.
However, I can't find the four valid nominations of The Collective..
One with the 53 postcount has been already voided before.
