StarGateWars Forums

what is the best concept album of all time? by concept album i mean an album where all the songs have a theme and tell the same story. the album is judged on both the quality of the story and the songs. my top 5 would be

metropllious pt 2 - dream theater
tommy - the who
operation mindcrime- queensryche
the wall - pink flyod
ok computer- radio head

in that order

but what do you think is the best concept album ever

David Bowie - The Rise and Fall of Ziggy Stardust and the Spiders from Mars
Yes – Tales from Topographic Oceans
Electric Light Orchestra – Eldorado
Pink Floyd – The Dark Side of the Moon
Pink Floyd - Animals

Mordack wrote:David Bowie - The Rise and Fall of Ziggy Stardust and the Spiders from Mars

I think you just won the thread But yeah - That album ^ would be my only suggestion due to the fact most of the bands I listen to have a "philosophy" or ideals which are mentioned throughout almost all their albums which isn't really what you're looking for. Thanks for wasting your time to read this

Biscuit wrote:

Mordack wrote:David Bowie - The Rise and Fall of Ziggy Stardust and the Spiders from Mars

I think you just won the thread But yeah - That album ^ would be my only suggestion due to the fact most of the bands I listen to have a "philosophy" or ideals which are mentioned throughout almost all their albums which isn't really what you're looking for. Thanks for wasting your time to read this

in this case why not mention system of a down?
"government, opression AARGH!" *repeat for 8-12 tracks and make a few albums off of it*

rofl

~soul

Biscuit wrote:

Mordack wrote:David Bowie - The Rise and Fall of Ziggy Stardust and the Spiders from Mars

I think you just won the thread But yeah - That album ^ would be my only suggestion due to the fact most of the bands I listen to have a "philosophy" or ideals which are mentioned throughout almost all their albums which isn't really what you're looking for. Thanks for wasting your time to read this

Heh, Ziggy Stardust was one of the first albums I ever listened to from start to finish. I had it on repeat so much that I'm surprised the CD didn't wear out. Sheer brilliance from start to finish.

Mordack wrote:

Biscuit wrote:

Mordack wrote:David Bowie - The Rise and Fall of Ziggy Stardust and the Spiders from Mars

I think you just won the thread But yeah - That album ^ would be my only suggestion due to the fact most of the bands I listen to have a "philosophy" or ideals which are mentioned throughout almost all their albums which isn't really what you're looking for. Thanks for wasting your time to read this

Heh, Ziggy Stardust was one of the first albums I ever listened to from start to finish. I had it on repeat so much that I'm surprised the CD didn't wear out. Sheer brilliance from start to finish.

Most of that whole album(do that call them that any more....note to papa not to date himself) was writen on a tour, and recorded on the fly. yes brilliant.

Juliet Letters
elvis costello

not a rock album by any standard, write for string quartet (that in it self for this artist make it special in it's own way), but with elements of jazz and rock mix in. Based around the fact that Juliet still receives letter to this day from the love lorn.

yea it's still called an album

first of all i have to apologise for leaving out bowie i cant belive he sliped my mind he should have had the number 4 slot for ziggy star dust

Juliet letters sounds like it would be worth a listen i might have to track it down

if you like string quartets with a twist i would recogmend apocalypto they are an incredable mix of heavyness and clasical music

well now im contributing instead of making snide remarks about SOAD.....

probably...
- The Voyage by In Fear and Faith
- Colors by Between the Buried and Me
- The Alchemy Index by Thrice

i cant choose between them really........

no offence but your snide remarks were better

Deaths_Rider wrote:no offence but your snide remarks were better

Nice ownage.

Mordack wrote:

Biscuit wrote:

Mordack wrote:David Bowie - The Rise and Fall of Ziggy Stardust and the Spiders from Mars

I think you just won the thread But yeah - That album ^ would be my only suggestion due to the fact most of the bands I listen to have a "philosophy" or ideals which are mentioned throughout almost all their albums which isn't really what you're looking for. Thanks for wasting your time to read this

Heh, Ziggy Stardust was one of the first albums I ever listened to from start to finish. I had it on repeat so much that I'm surprised the CD didn't wear out. Sheer brilliance from start to finish.

Excellent stuff indeed. Was listening to Bowies stuff the other day (again ), a true artist.

There's a band called MGMT or something and I listened to some of their stuff. One song named "Weekend Wars" - I'd swear it was from a Bowie album.

Deaths_Rider wrote:no offence but your snide remarks were better

heh not like i need your approval i like what i like and i pride myself in having.... odd tastes in music...... i mean back in a Technical Drawing (blueprints and such) class, i was listening to Misery Signals new album Controller, one of my classmates was curious what i was listening to and was surprised to hear metalish stuffs.......

well i might aswell throw Tool - 10,000 days into the mix, even though some tracks are repetitive etc...... still good music, if you can just not focus on the pseudo intellectuallism they so frequently spout.... (like those ppl who play video games and hate them for their lack of realism..... its a GAME its S'POSED to be FUN. and hey, CoD4 is fun, but thats another story...... you get my point tho.)

~soul

Mordack wrote:Yes – Tales from Topographic Oceans

Im a little bit turned on by your mad Musick Skillz there Mordack!