StarGateWars Forums

I was thinking this morning (I know Me Think, Impossible). But never the less, I had a thought. How hard would it be to add the code to Main for a recall option on your Mothership while it's exploring. Even now we can send a message to our submerged subs to return or at least surface to receive further instructions. So it just seems logical that you should be able to contact a starship even though it's in a game. Don't know how much coding it would involve but believe it would improve realism and functionality of the game.

Yeah, that would help a lot. Though, just to make it harder, it shouldn't be instantanous recall. From the moment you recall it, a time period needs to elapse as it turns back around. Maybe an hour?

Also, any planet it can be trucking back needs to be abandon as well so the ship can return faster.

not sure but i think this has been already suggested and got negative response.

has been suggested repeatedly, and generally shot down.

Its highly exploitable as far as protecting your MS, and unless it comes with some hefty penilties it will not go through.

Player A has massive MS, sends it out exploring to protect it. Everyone knows when it was sent out. They expect it back at a set time. but he recalls it 3 hrs early, masses all the others MS's and leves his in a state of junk and unrepaired. You can never get revenge. It would just be another tactic for hit and run/gorrilla fighters.

Fallout wrote:not sure but i think this has been already suggested and got negative response.

That makes no sense Fallout, why would anyone dislike this suggestion? It makes logical, perfect sense.

And Spyridon, just FYI your MS doesn't tow the planet back. It jsut breaks it out of orbit and "points" it in the direction of your realm, says so in the section above your planet summary.

Lore wrote:has been suggested repeatedly, and generally shot down.

Its highly exploitable as far as protecting your MS, and unless it comes with some hefty penilties it will not go through.

Player A has massive MS, sends it out exploring to protect it. Everyone knows when it was sent out. They expect it back at a set time. but he recalls it 3 hrs early, masses all the others MS's and leves his in a state of junk and unrepaired. You can never get revenge. It would just be another tactic for hit and run/gorrilla fighters.

If you add the time delay in the recall, it would slow that down to some extent. Even say just to cut in half the normal time (24 hrs).

Lonewolf1968 wrote:

Lore wrote:has been suggested repeatedly, and generally shot down.

Its highly exploitable as far as protecting your MS, and unless it comes with some hefty penilties it will not go through.

Player A has massive MS, sends it out exploring to protect it. Everyone knows when it was sent out. They expect it back at a set time. but he recalls it 3 hrs early, masses all the others MS's and leves his in a state of junk and unrepaired. You can never get revenge. It would just be another tactic for hit and run/gorrilla fighters.

If you add the time delay in the recall, it would slow that down to some extent. Even say just to cut in half the normal time (24 hrs).

point still is, it gives the MS owner a stretigic advantage as they know when it returns, not everyone looking for it.

As I said, its been suggested and discussed and generally shot down because its exploitable. Without some definite downfalls, why give the snipers/gorilla fighters another tool in their arsinal? 90% of MS sent out are not looking for planets, but protection.

What about the consequence of recalling it be that you can't send it out again for 24 hours after it returns back to the hanger bay due to the engines burning out from being maxed out on the return?

@LW, I haven't been able to see that since I got all ten planets which has been a while now. Point can still be made; it's not there to monitor the planet drifting toward the planet so the planet can veer off course or get stolen by another person.

Well... I think, you SHOULD be able to 'recall' your mothership within the turn change (i.e. if you sent your MS out while there were 28minutes left in a turn, you have 27minutes (just to be safe) to recall it, if you sent your MS out while there were still 2 minutes left, you would only have slightly less than 2 minutes to recall)

As this would be realistic, as it would be realistic to shout a "come back!" to a friend who accidentally drove off without you (not implying that that ever happened to me)...

Lore wrote:

Lonewolf1968 wrote:

Lore wrote:has been suggested repeatedly, and generally shot down.

Its highly exploitable as far as protecting your MS, and unless it comes with some hefty penilties it will not go through.

Player A has massive MS, sends it out exploring to protect it. Everyone knows when it was sent out. They expect it back at a set time. but he recalls it 3 hrs early, masses all the others MS's and leves his in a state of junk and unrepaired. You can never get revenge. It would just be another tactic for hit and run/gorrilla fighters.

If you add the time delay in the recall, it would slow that down to some extent. Even say just to cut in half the normal time (24 hrs).

point still is, it gives the MS owner a stretigic advantage as they know when it returns, not everyone looking for it.

As I said, its been suggested and discussed and generally shot down because its exploitable. Without some definite downfalls, why give the snipers/gorilla fighters another tool in their arsinal? 90% of MS sent out are not looking for planets, but protection.

I agree with Lore. Bad idea.

~Norbe~

It might be possible in reality but that doesn't necessarily mean it's good for game mechanics. It probably wouldn't be hard to code, but its the type of thing you would put in a game against CPUs who won't complain about people who have better/cheaper strategies than them.

Hmm, kinda like Nox, great when you use it, really annoying when others use it.

Much as I love new idea's. On balance I would say NO to this one

csp4.0 wrote:Well... I think, you SHOULD be able to 'recall' your mothership within the turn change (i.e. if you sent your MS out while there were 28minutes left in a turn, you have 27minutes (just to be safe) to recall it, if you sent your MS out while there were still 2 minutes left, you would only have slightly less than 2 minutes to recall)

As this would be realistic, as it would be realistic to shout a "come back!" to a friend who accidentally drove off without you (not implying that that ever happened to me)...

and I agree, just like i suggested when a planet is stolen, if you strike back in the same turn the planet isnt lost, if you strike back in the next turn then you only lose 1 turn getting it back. The entire MS/planet steal set up is so stupid.

It's highly exploitable if you can recall it and send it out back immediately after massing. But if you place a cost on it where you can't send it out when you do RECALL it for 24 hours then that leaves a window of being massed.

So the choice is, do you recall it and leave it open for 24 hours or do you let it run out and let it return on its own?

In the end it's all up to the user.

How about we run it in the beta server?

Lore wrote:

csp4.0 wrote:Well... I think, you SHOULD be able to 'recall' your mothership within the turn change (i.e. if you sent your MS out while there were 28minutes left in a turn, you have 27minutes (just to be safe) to recall it, if you sent your MS out while there were still 2 minutes left, you would only have slightly less than 2 minutes to recall)

As this would be realistic, as it would be realistic to shout a "come back!" to a friend who accidentally drove off without you (not implying that that ever happened to me)...

and I agree, just like i suggested when a planet is stolen, if you strike back in the same turn the planet isnt lost, if you strike back in the next turn then you only lose 1 turn getting it back. The entire MS/planet steal set up is so stupid.

Both very good ideas well thought out!!