StarGateWars Forums

SuperSaiyan wrote:

deni wrote:

SuperSaiyan wrote:your telling me the only reason for the GC is for people to insult one another and not to try and have a fun easy going war?

You do seem to miss the point again.

NO one has anything against a bit of roleplaying in the GC. If they want to roleplay there, then non roleplaying, connected to the topic at hand, non forum rules breaking posts should be allowed as well.

If someone wants an entirely role playing threads limited to a certain setting/environment, then they should use the roleplaying section.

why? whats the point? there is an RP thread in GC, for RP only....

and in general there is a thread for pretty much everything else, why can that not be deemed acceptable for this war? you don't want to RP post in the other thread

so I should post say battle logs in General? Instead of the GC? LOL

Maybe I should limit the market to only roleplaying posts and let people post threads in General?

SuperSaiyan wrote:go for it, I don't mind playing thread tennis...

and no, battle logs should be posted whereever appropriate, if its being worked into RP, then let it go in the RP thread in GC, if it is being posted by itself, the post it in the DISCUSSION thread....

when it comes down to it, the threads are 2 halves of the same whole, one with the RP of a war, and the other with the dribble, all we have done is seperate it

So battle logs do belong now in General?

Interesting

Will you answer my question?

Do battle logs belong in General now?

Or is it an exception made only for this particular thread?

And if it is, why.

well make a GC ROLE PLAY WAR FORUM THEN. prob solved

SuperSaiyan wrote:I was told to keep the RP/discussion seperated and that is what I have done, do I agree with it, absolutely

I believe this is what is creating this whole situation........ who told you.

War stats or whatever you call them should not be posted in General. End of.

SuperSaiyan wrote:

deni wrote:
Or is it an exception made only for this particular thread?

And if it is, why.

certain battle logs have always been posted in general, you act as if it is the first time...


I was told to keep the RP/discussion seperated and that is what I have done, do I agree with it, absolutely

Big raids? Big naq hits?

Yes, they have been posted in general.

What about war threads?

Any there besides the current one?


@JT: There is a RP section as Jack pointed out already.

But we aren't allowed to post battle logs because that shows the defence? Or am I wrong? And my post was not aimed to derail the thread, I like roleplaying as much as the next person but as I do not know the terminator storyline I had no idea what was going on. I know I could've made it a little more clear by saying who attacked me and so on but I didn't know that was a part of roleplaying. My post clearly states that TTF attacked me and lost. I mean how hard is it to derive that from the post?

deni wrote:

SuperSaiyan wrote:

deni wrote:

SuperSaiyan wrote:your telling me the only reason for the GC is for people to insult one another and not to try and have a fun easy going war?

You do seem to miss the point again.

NO one has anything against a bit of roleplaying in the GC. If they want to roleplay there, then non roleplaying, connected to the topic at hand, non forum rules breaking posts should be allowed as well.

If someone wants an entirely role playing threads limited to a certain setting/environment, then they should use the roleplaying section.

why? whats the point? there is an RP thread in GC, for RP only....

and in general there is a thread for pretty much everything else, why can that not be deemed acceptable for this war? you don't want to RP post in the other thread

so I should post say battle logs in General? Instead of the GC? LOL

Maybe I should limit the market to only roleplaying posts and let people post threads in General?

i have to agree with deni here, the GC can't just be limited to Roleplay, its for all the war threads and the such, i'd say most of the GC threads have little RP in it?

RP may be fun for some people, but some people don't want to RP or simply don't have the time and i don't think they should be told to roleplay in a thread they are directly involved in but isn't RP based?