StarGateWars Forums

After someone to do some graphics... so i was wondering who you recon is the best sig maker ingame?


before a mod attempts to move this... I'm not asking for the service of a sig maker...

I'm asking the players opinions on who is the best sig maker to get abit of general information

Title can be fought between Nightmare/Zeb, Neimenljivi, DarkDayz, J-Ronimo, Lord Neqa'el, SuperSaiyan, Castiel, Awaken Knight, Murkar, HairMan, Skunky...
However I'm too lazy to find work from each. Well I bought a sig from majority of these, so I could post past sigs attaached to each maker..

Uhhh wait! This shall be answered in the upcoming SGW 2011 Awards lol!

Castiel by far. SS and Lord Neqa'el. AK is also highly skilled.

JT and ETL have been known to make good sigs when they put their mind to it. I know for a fact that JT can be a great artist.

I'd make them all under the table any day of the week when I was still doing it. I used to woop nightmares ass from here to timbuktu.

But then.... I am retired now and not as practised, it's been a year since I touched photoshop.

Semper wrote:I'd make them all under the table any day of the week when I was still doing it. I used to woop nightmares ass from here to timbuktu.

But then.... I am retired now and not as practised, it's been a year since I touched photoshop.

"pics or it didn't happen"

Phalax

For me, Darkdayz was miles beyond anyone else, although i thought Lord Neqa'el, J-Ronimo, Nightmare and Semper were also very good.

Shame that none of these still play the game.

Reschef wrote:

Semper wrote:I'd make them all under the table any day of the week when I was still doing it. I used to woop nightmares ass from here to timbuktu.

But then.... I am retired now and not as practised, it's been a year since I touched photoshop.

"pics or it didn't happen"

Oh sorry.. did pops mention Dark Dayz? I wasn't better than him. He's the only person on the forums in my opinion that could make a sig better than me and if I was going to be 'realistic' Murkar could rustle something shiny on a good day... otherwise he just got a bit too carried away with his 4D's and making it look like someone had had a fit with a paintbrush rather than make a sig with any actualy meaning to the render involved.

Pic.. my current signature. There used to be many who wore my sigs a while ago... Man Called Jim had two from me, buck had three, wold359 had one, badwolf had two, Lore had four, super saiyan had two (well one was a bar), I made most of Nem's ones.. it was me or Dark Dayz and I could go on...

Murkar makes great avatars and sigs, may I recomend Retribution as well.... he is really good!

Kjarkur wrote:Castiel by far. SS and Lord Neqa'el. AK is also highly skilled.

JT and ETL have been known to make good sigs when they put their mind to it. I know for a fact that JT can be a great artist.

slayers fifth made my avatar but he is retired , although i would definatly vote him one of the best

I forgot about SlayerS, he was highly skilled aswell. I'd put him up there with Castiel and SS.

Tetrismonkey wrote:No one loves me. Perhaps I should actually make people pay for mine.

I love you


Still... Neimenljivi is best

Now I've noticed a displeasing ammount of people mentioning SS and i'd like to be quite clear here in saying he's mediocre at best. By that i mean if he got luck he'd be on par with the average sig maker. He would be lucky if his "Mona Lisa" were to be accepted by the community, to be worn on these forums.

There is no single best sigmaker.

There are many varying levels of skill, but no single one that is the "best".
Why?
Because quality of a sig depends to a large degree on the audience, not just on its creator.