StarGateWars Forums

These are the forums for the GateWa.rs family of text-based space-centred PBBGs
https://talk.gatewa.rs/

1990119 - haha77 - Suspected Multi *Resolved*

https://talk.gatewa.rs/viewtopic.php?t=195311

Page 1 of 2

1990119 - haha77 - Suspected Multi *Resolved*

Posted: Sat Oct 27, 2012 9:35 pm
by woodsy1
Hey guys.
I have reason to believe this guy is a multi... sadly i dont know the other account tho sorry...

here are a sample of logs from my officers spy and attack logs...
Spy
[spoiler]
    Oct 26, 01:56 ?????? Sabotage Infiltrated 854,251 details
    Oct 26, 01:56 ?????? Sabotage Infiltrated 908,778 details
    Oct 26, 01:55 ?????? Sabotage Infiltrated 819,977 details
    Oct 26, 01:55 ?????? Sabotage Infiltrated 872,316 details
    Oct 26, 01:54 ?????? Sabotage Infiltrated 927,996 details
    Oct 26, 01:54 ?????? Sabotage Infiltrated 987,230 details
    Oct 26, 01:54 ?????? Sabotage Infiltrated 1,000,000 details
[/spoiler]

Attack
[spoiler]
    Oct 26, 01:57 haha77 1,718,142,937 Naquadah stolen 15 0 102,767 6 354,628,530,586 details
    Oct 26, 01:57 haha77 569,663,903 Naquadah stolen 3 0 20,646 6 357,903,067,632 details
    Oct 26, 01:57 haha77 783,074,825 Naquadah stolen 3 0 17,617 6 323,999,377,578 details
    Oct 26, 01:57 haha77 1,051,107,147 Naquadah stolen 3 0 20,821 6 348,220,930,640 details
    Oct 26, 01:57 haha77 1,524,571,204 Naquadah stolen 3 0 20,917 5 337,150,578,571 details
    Oct 26, 01:57 haha77 1,872,161,710 Naquadah stolen 3 0 21,013 6 349,021,143,788 details
    Oct 26, 01:57 haha77 2,533,045,288 Naquadah stolen 3 0 21,108 6 334,727,833,789 details
    Oct 26, 01:57 haha77 3,889,657,416 Naquadah stolen 3 0 21,205 6 350,281,147,918 details
    Oct 26, 01:57 haha77 4,548,528,395 Naquadah stolen 3 0 21,303 5 350,981,150,212 details
    Oct 26, 01:57 haha77 6,429,121,063 Naquadah stolen 3 0 21,401 6 343,422,599,125 details
    Oct 26, 01:57 haha77 7,999,121,472 Naquadah stolen 3 0 21,500 5 354,628,530,586 details
[/spoiler]

Now you might say that this is simple that he just sabbed defence away then attacked. but.
I have run the numbers and this is not possible as both my officer and him were at 29 level covert and my officer had 1,000,000 spys.
this would mean that he would require minimum of 1,383,282 to sab safely.
So he had to have aouther account doing the sabbing....
he doesnt have any officer or a CO or an alliance...

The other thing that is not concreate but worth noteing is that he came completely out of no where and just starting massing everyone in our alliance. brand new account and when asked he said he was a past member of the alliance when first started and that he didnt like seeing it like this...
now what iam thinking is that its a guy who we have farmed or something didnt want to get his normally account messy so made new one to do it..

I agree with what people will say none of this is very concreate but its quite fishy and worth a look into.

cheers,

Woodsy

Re: 1990119 - haha77 - Suspected Multi

Posted: Sat Oct 27, 2012 11:57 pm
by Kikaz
Lol. He's been targeting my officers recently, and sent some pretty funny messages, because with less than half of my turnly unit production I sabbed away something he could farm back in a turn and how stupid I was for wasting UU :P

Re: 1990119 - haha77 - Suspected Multi

Posted: Sun Oct 28, 2012 12:27 pm
by woodsy1
lol thats pretty funny! :P
any admin can check this out?

Re: 1990119 - haha77 - Suspected Multi

Posted: Mon Oct 29, 2012 3:51 am
by borg
Very strange that LoveMe ID:1989938 has now taking overe this random massing role
and that haha77 account has been deleted !

Re: 1990119 - haha77 - Suspected Multi

Posted: Mon Oct 29, 2012 11:02 am
by Kikaz
Lol yup new account also massed my officers, its funny though I dont know any of them their jusr new accounts that made rank 1 their Co :P

Re: 1990119 - haha77 - Suspected Multi

Posted: Mon Oct 29, 2012 12:31 pm
by borg
rank 1 always attracts hangers on - its like people who send begging letters to lottery jackpot winners.

ID:1989938 LoveMe definately looks odd - even has the same writing/spelling style as haha77

This is a message from haha77

allways but it hurts when someone steals soooooooo much from me ...btw why do you suck so much...you used to be adleast medium good when the real EK was made now it's just painfull to watch your lame ass attack and MS in my logs lol

This is a message from LoveMe

well hello again...you might be wondering why i massed all your members exept 2 that are on ppt and himla...well my friend haha77 said if i was bored i have few targets...anyway you can strip my acc if you wish i live for massing so i hope to see you in my logs soon becouse i am very bored...soon as i drip off ppt afkorse,,,anyway this is total loss for now..

My reason for believing its the same person is the little dots between sentences, thats kind of an unconscious thing people do and would not think about when pretending to be somebody else. Not to mention the similar bad spelling of simple words.

Re: 1990119 - haha77 - Suspected Multi

Posted: Mon Oct 29, 2012 12:50 pm
by frans
I've also been examining their activity. It appears that both accounts are accessed from the same time zone, and their owners even have the same schedule. I suspect the owner(s) of the accounts both go to school/same school based on the quality of the messages.

Re: 1990119 - haha77 - Suspected Multi

Posted: Mon Oct 29, 2012 1:34 pm
by Juliette
Tetrismonkey wrote:
Frans wrote:I've also been examining their activity. It appears that both accounts are accessed from the same time zone, and their owners even have the same schedule. I suspect the owner(s) of the accounts both go to school/same school based on the quality of the messages.
Care to elaborate further?
They send / attack at the same time within a time frame of about 8 hours. ;) And given the quality of their messages (same mistakes) you could leap to the conclusion that they have the same poor teacher..

Aside from the time zone, I would not go so far as to say same school. Just the same type-hand misalignment. :) (Strong suggestion -> same person.)
Also: Hi Frans, where did you suddenly come from?

Re: 1990119 - haha77 - Suspected Multi

Posted: Mon Oct 29, 2012 2:12 pm
by woodsy1
thanks for your interest on this one guys great that people take interest in helping this game to stay cheater free!

Re: 1990119 - haha77 - Suspected Multi

Posted: Mon Oct 29, 2012 3:01 pm
by frans
Juliette wrote:They send / attack at the same time within a time frame of about 8 hours. ;) And given the quality of their messages (same mistakes) you could leap to the conclusion that they have the same poor teacher.

That's the general idea.

Also: HI to you too!

Re: 1990119 - haha77 - Suspected Multi

Posted: Wed Oct 31, 2012 2:16 am
by woodsy1
bumping this can it get seen he is becomeing a real problem

Re: 1990119 - haha77 - Suspected Multi

Posted: Wed Oct 31, 2012 2:23 am
by The Doctor
woodsy1 wrote:bumping this can it get seen he is becomeing a real problem


viewtopic.php?f=209&t=195366

Will be emailed to Admin in my weekly email :)

Might do it tonight, or over the next day or two

Re: 1990119 - haha77 - Suspected Multi

Posted: Wed Oct 31, 2012 12:26 pm
by woodsy1
o right sweet :) thanks!

Re: 1990119 - haha77 - Suspected Multi

Posted: Thu Nov 01, 2012 11:27 pm
by borg
last night he has a 280m army and 10 planets - when i get up this morning he has 32m army and 2 planets - wierd - unless he already has a new account and is movng resources to it - or if he was legit he could have just brokered out all his UU and merlined his planets till he can jump on PPT again

Re: 1990119 - haha77 - Suspected Multi

Posted: Sun Nov 04, 2012 4:30 am
by Clarkey
Just thought i'd pop my head in my favourite section, and I must say i'm disappointed that people still don't seem to actually READ things properly and IDENTIFY significant bits of text that could potentially and easily be used to identify who the culprit is or who it may be. Having swiftly read this thread I already have a #1 prime suspect identified. Admittedly this is due to my experience in this section, but even without that I would still have come to the same quick conclusion of a possible suspect.

As i'm not active in this community anymore I'm going to throw you a bone, but you'll have to do most of the leg work yourself, which isn't that much to be honest. I will narrow this down for you to just one paragraph and leave it all in your capable hands to come to the same conclusion that i did within a few minutes. The paragraph is:

borg wrote:This is a message from LoveMe

well hello again...you might be wondering why i massed all your members exept 2 that are on ppt and himla...well my friend haha77 said if i was bored i have few targets...anyway you can strip my acc if you wish i live for massing so i hope to see you in my logs soon becouse i am very bored...soon as i drip off ppt afkorse,,,anyway this is total loss for now..


I won't be coming back again anytime soon, so make me proud...
All times are UTC-08:00
Page 1 of 2

Powered by phpBB® Forum Software © phpBB Limited