Page 1 of 3
Who would you say is the winner ?
Posted: Thu Jul 04, 2013 9:53 am
by Guild
Team FS
Original enemy pop-165,198,328
Kill count -206,139,142
135% amount of army lost
Team DDE
Original enemy pop-1,882,015,041
kill count- 295,850,582
16% amount of army lost
whats your opinion on this, as the game thinks the Forgotten serenity alliance won
Re: Who would you say is the winner ?
Posted: Thu Jul 04, 2013 9:54 am
by Catsupmotor
The game is always right. FS won!
Re: Who would you say is the winner ?
Posted: Thu Jul 04, 2013 9:59 am
by Guild
Lord Katsumoto wrote:The game is always right. FS won!
bitter french persons view not recognised
Re: Who would you say is the winner ?
Posted: Thu Jul 04, 2013 10:04 am
by Catsupmotor
You can call me french any day except today. Happy 4th of July!
But its obvious blood war is broken. Don't fault Fs for using it, but its a pointless "win". Doesn't mean much.
Re: Who would you say is the winner ?
Posted: Thu Jul 04, 2013 10:09 am
by Clockwork
Didn't DDE initiate that Bloodwar?
Looks like its just using the kill count to pick the winner, so from that point of view FS won, rather than percentage of army killed in which DDE would have won.
I can't remember what the update says is the correct outcome, either post something in the bugs forum or try and attend the Admin meet this Friday and see what the outcome is.
Regardless, hope both sides had a good time
Re: Who would you say is the winner ?
Posted: Thu Jul 04, 2013 10:15 am
by Mikgamer
ROFL typical GW...don't fix a major / obvious problem for monthsssss
Re: Who would you say is the winner ?
Posted: Thu Jul 04, 2013 10:18 am
by RepliMagni
Not enough info there - stats destroyed? ascended losses? number descended? etc
Purely from those stats though, you could make the claim that FS killed the higher proportion of enemy troops compared to their own army sizes; or that they lost a higher percentage of their own troops; or that, as neither alliance disbanded, no one won
Re: Who would you say is the winner ?
Posted: Thu Jul 04, 2013 10:19 am
by Juliette
Guild wrote:Team FS
Original enemy pop-165,198,328
Kill count -206,139,142
135% amount of army lost
Team DDE
Original enemy pop-1,882,015,041
kill count- 295,850,582
16% amount of army lost
whats your opinion on this, as the game thinks the Forgotten serenity alliance won
FS:
Original Army: 165,198,328
Kill Count: 206,139,142
Killed % of Original Army: 124.7%
DDE:
Original Army: 1,882,015,041
Kill Count: 295,850,582
Killed % of Original Army: 15.7%
FS has killed DDE troops in the amount of 124.7% of their (FS) original total population.
DDE has killed FS troops in the amount of 15.7% of their (DDE) original total population.
Game says FS wins.
Not broken. Just have to look at "killed" instead of "lost".
Additionally, what Magni said. Need a lot more information to really decide a winner.
Re: Who would you say is the winner ?
Posted: Thu Jul 04, 2013 10:23 am
by Guild
Clockwork wrote:Didn't DDE initiate that Bloodwar?
Looks like its just using the kill count to pick the winner, so from that point of view FS won, rather than percentage of army killed in which DDE would have won.
I can't remember what the update says is the correct outcome, either post something in the bugs forum or try and attend the Admin meet this Friday and see what the outcome is.
Regardless, hope both sides had a good time
nah FS initiated it
Lord Katsumoto wrote:You can call me french any day except today. Happy 4th of July!
But its obvious blood war is broken. Don't fault Fs for using it, but its a pointless "win". Doesn't mean much.
im not faulting FS for doing it, not whatsoever.
what is annoying is that we've done bloodwar many times and have mades topics in which both sides agree that how the winner is decided is broke, but jason doesnt do jack **Filtered**, as repli said
and it is broken as their is no way physically possible that we could kill more before they kill enough, as their main stats were on ppt for the start (again not faulting FS for doing it like that)
Re: Who would you say is the winner ?
Posted: Thu Jul 04, 2013 10:25 am
by Juliette
Should be fixed along with ME though (counting losses as well).
And then used for war counters through cumulative values..
Re: Who would you say is the winner ?
Posted: Thu Jul 04, 2013 10:29 am
by Guild
Juliette wrote:Should be fixed along with ME though (counting losses as well).
And then used for war counters through cumulative values..
you can have a look through the previous bloodwar suggestion threads there is about 3 of them...
Re: Who would you say is the winner ?
Posted: Thu Jul 04, 2013 10:30 am
by Juliette
Guild wrote:Juliette wrote:Should be fixed along with ME though (counting losses as well).
And then used for war counters through cumulative values..
you can have a look through the previous bloodwar suggestion threads there is about 3 of them...
Nah, I just like repeating myself. It is no big deal.
Re: Who would you say is the winner ?
Posted: Thu Jul 04, 2013 10:38 am
by moses
lulz F.S tottaly won
Re: Who would you say is the winner ?
Posted: Thu Jul 04, 2013 12:37 pm
by Field Marshall
Fact: FS won
GG Guild, unlucky, 4-0?
Re: Who would you say is the winner ?
Posted: Thu Jul 04, 2013 1:47 pm
by Guild
Field Marshall wrote:Fact: FS won
GG Guild, unlucky, 4-0?
pretty disapointing from you and drah tbh, could of killed so much more especially since you guys initiated and had 3 on ppt ready .... very disappointing
#but if you need to do it this way, because of lazy jason then whatever , we will be here as soon as this bloodwar drop with uu ready to keep going
your guys emptied yourself out nicely