Community Opinion the Job the Moderators are doing.

[Ero`Sore]

*Smoosh Edit - Read before voting*:
Guide to voting from Eros

Anything but very good is bad.
If it's average they are not doing good enough,
If its good/bad then thats not just good,
If its below average its bad,
If its a bad job they immediatly need to be replaced.

Many people believe that the moderators are not doing a good job. Many people believe they are meerly role playing gods of the forums. Many people believe the mods are biased/fast triggered/irresposible/immature/unprofessional.

While some mods are good, I believe the Majority of them need to be dismissed and replaced with able bodied men and women.

Here are two interesting quotes from the mods that I have found:

Why woulnd't I save stuff I could use to hurt the moderators after they cheat me out of my position?

I have yet to decide if I will post it or not.

Mate, if I was you I'd quit while you still have some small amount of dignity left.

Do you think that people will be entirely suprised about anything you can bring from the mod forum?

Do you think they will surprised that we talk about things, threads, people on the forum?

Do you think they will be surprised that we even sometimes argue amongst ourselves?

SHOCK! HORROR!

You have already had your say in here and another couple of threads - and even the community opinion has not gone your way.

You were removed from your position because you were unsuitable for it. Surely you must accept that as the truth - because that is the way a lot of people view it. And that logic is based on the fact that that according to you Spacey definately called you a woman, despite the fact most people disagree.

Or does that only work because you said it?

You need to face up to the fact that you are not always right - and if you keep on down this path you will only serve to turn more people away from you,

Stop this now and you might gain back some respect.

While I have everything of what has been said and done in their forums saved, I believe that it is not necessary to post, as Wolf359 admitted to the things that go on there, and I leave it to your immagination.

Agreed, clean my house plz

All post after this not regarding leaving this war will be removed when i arent drunk and a warning send to all as thats withing the rule since it has been asked both by the maker and by mods so many times for spam to stop.

Moderators are modding our forums while under the influence of Alcohol? God knows what else they're on when they "enforce the rules".

Which by the way, have you noticed there are no rules? The rules are under the interpretation of the Moderating guidelines.
But heres a shocker.. there are NO guidelines on how to moderate and what is right/wrong in their moderating section.

So the question is, what is your overall opinion on the moderators?

Also I have another request. Ignore whatever the moderators say, as they are the ones on trial here. They will naturally lie to save their own skins. They will talk as a regular forum member, but you can figure out who they are because they will be the ones defending themselves.
This is a poll for THE ENTIRE SGW community minus the moderators/administrators.

Furthermore, there are 20 moderators. So the first 20 very good votes will not count, as they will surely vote themselves as very good. Sadly they all have multi accounts so there will probably be over 40 votes from them, but I'm sure the community outnumbers the moderators+their multies.

[Legendary Apophis]

They don't do bad job at all now, I've seen past, I see now...it's clear it has been worse in past. Depends of point of view, bu for me it was worse BEFORE smoosh became admin & all new mods came in.

[Almost38]

there bad and gd

[AncientAnubis]

About average I'd say, but I don't get involved with the moderators enough to really know everything they do and don't do.

[Psi Kiya Trist]

This is a poll for THE ENTIRE SGW community minus the moderators/administrators.

i doubt you're the one to call that. since you seem utterly incapable of figuring out which side of that line i stand.

~_+Psi Kiya Trist+_~

[Juliette]

Furthermore, there are 20 moderators. So the first 20 very good votes will not count, as they will surely vote themselves as very good. Sadly they all have multi accounts so there will probably be over 40 votes from them, but I'm sure the community outnumbers the moderators+their multies.

This is amusing.. you have just destroyed the statistical credibility this poll might ever have had.
Seriously, if you want to poll the community (several thousand people) you really shouldn't worry about 20-odd mods voting for themselves as Very Good. What is 20 in a total votage of 2000? And that is taking one VERY low figure for "The Community".

Anyway.. I voted "Very Good". Maybe I am silly, maybe I'm just a fan of mods.. (lol) or maybe I see what these forums would be without a moderating team.
Hey! Who is to say.

But seriously Eros.. you cannot discount 20 votes because there are 20 moderators. You just can't.. not without destroying your poll.

Otherwise, I love your tenacity.

[Ero`Sore]

The only thing I did by destroying the first 20 very good votes is I improved the accuracy/credibility of this poll.

I am not asking for the mods to be removed (yet). I am simply asking on the opinion of whoever reads. I want them to voice their opinions on what they think of the current mod team. If the poll will show that they are not doing a good job, I will ask for the team to be replaced/reorganized.

Moderating will never go away, but the team moderating team is not a monarchy and can be replaced if we wish.

Furthermore, please do not spam this thread with my issues of spacey, the mods' issues with me, me massing the mods etc.

Keep it on topic.

[Almost38]

Furthermore, please do not spam this thread with my issues of spacey, the mods' issues with me, me massing the mods etc.

Keep it on topic.

that is the whole point of the topic u would of never made this thread if it wasnt for those issues

[Ero`Sore]

The reason for me making the topic is not what is to be debated. What is to be debated is are the Moderators doing a good job?

[Juliette]

The only thing I did by destroying the first 20 very good votes is I improved the accuracy/credibility of this poll.

Actually, if I remember my statistics classes correctly, you should also discount the 20 worst votes. THAT would be improving accuracy.
But indeed.. I know what you're doing, and why.. but I'm afraid you'll lose this poll as well.. even with the elimination of the top votes.
Nothing personal there, I just think the Community will not be tricked into voting away the one source of order they have.

I am not asking for the mods to be removed (yet). I am simply asking on the opinion of whoever reads. I want them to voice their opinions on what they think of the current mod team. If the poll will show that they are not doing a good job, I will ask for the team to be replaced/reorganized.

Ah, indeed.. a veritable Vox Populi..
Now if you manage to keep old issues out of this, you might indeed prove there was SOME justification for your earlier appointment.
Let's wait and see what comes from this.

Moderating will never go away, but the team moderating team is not a monarchy and can be replaced if we wish.

I beg to differ.. as the forums are quite the Monarchy, Forum/Jason being it's King and the Team being it's governors, dukes and barons..
It's definitely no democracy, but thank God, democracy is overrated anyway.

Furthermore, please do not spam this thread with my issues of spacey, the mods' issues with me, me massing the mods etc.

That's funny in itself, but of course.. it would benefit the poll.

(I did keep on topic, didn't I? PM if you disagree?)

[Nimras]

Agreed, clean my house plz

All post after this not regarding leaving this war will be removed when i arent drunk and a warning send to all as thats withing the rule since it has been asked both by the maker and by mods so many times for spam to stop.

Moderators are modding our forums while under the influence of Alcohol? God knows what else they're on when they "enforce the rules".

Hmm lol i like it you dont read what i said i would mod when i arent drunk. And that i didnt mod anything in thoese hours also shows it. But nvm i will not answer anymore in these areas or post since you wont listen.

[Ero`Sore]

While you did not moderate THAT post when you were drunk, you did under the influence of alcohol DECIDE to moderate it in the future.

[Juliette]

When I shoot a man in mid-air who is falling to his death, did I commit murder?

Trivialities.. keep to the primary issue.

[Psi Kiya Trist]

When I shoot a man in mid-air who is falling to his death, did I commit murder?

Trivialities.. keep to the primary issue.

even more interesting if the man who loaded the gun, was the same one who was falling to his death...

~_+Psi Kiya Trist+_~

[Almost38]