~~~~JACKS POST~~~~~~

[Sephiroth]

Mods are there to keep people in CHECK thats all Jack did. If you act like a idiot you deserved to be called one.

[Sephiroth]

Wow amazed i am. It's all a matter of opinion. Your opinion is he's bad, and the rest of the sane world thinks he did nothing wrong. Get your sobs out and suck it up.

[Riposte]

Not really an insult if its true.

We've already established AGA's an idiot, so I never insulted him by your logic. Therefore you have no argument.


I'm done with this thread.

Lol yeah that wins it.

[Nimras]

Right you need 9 warnings within 90 days to get a perm ban.

1. AGA dont have that so NO Jack cant perm ban his ass unless he goes true the prober channels if he wants a perm ban before time.

2. AGA got a warning and ban for his last racist remark which Jack changed to well as you all can see is posted here.

3. Secondly the change AGA did does not break rules.

4. Will people please talk prober about this issue weather you like Jack or not we still do have rules to be kept.

Nimras

[deni]

I propose a change to the rules/guidelines: all racist slurs are to be edited out with "sorry, i am an idiot" cause everyone who needs to sink that low IS definitely an idiot.


People tend to forget too easily that this a game and this forums is about that game ergo we should be here for the fun. Some invest more of their free time on this forums to mod or administer it, but it is still a hobby, not a job. If they see their position as mods as a job, then maybe it is time for them to resign, cause it makes them lose what they were here for in the first place ... the fun


Anyways, my position is the same as stated in the mod forums, I will not bother to post it here as everyone knows what is posted there anyways, right Nimras?

[Nimras]

Warning he recieved was for saying this with a quote of REK:

[spoiler]

Warning.JPG

[/spoiler]

Jack Edited to this:

[spoiler]

Jack.JPG

[/spoiler]

Now warning was just Jack did what he should and banned AGA for a right thing.

I propose a change to the rules/guidelines: all racist slurs are to be edited out with "sorry, i am an idiot" cause everyone who needs to sink that low IS definitely an idiot.


People tend to forget too easily that this a game and this forums is about that game ergo we should be here for the fun. Some invest more of their free time on this forums to mod or administer it, but it is still a hobby, not a job. If they see their position as mods as a job, then maybe it is time for them to resign, cause it makes them lose what they were here for in the first place ... the fun


Anyways, my position is the same as stated in the mod forums, I will not bother to post it here as everyone knows what is posted there anyways, right Nimras?

I will gladly answer:

1. Being a mod/supermod/admin is a job with rules yes we should have fun but formost be here to uphold the rules while having fun.

2. No editing someone post with a insult or saying they are idiots even tho deserving it is not our place as mods/supermods/admin we are here to be unbiased and neutral.

3. And Deni please give me more credit than that will ya.

[Donovan5]

1) If you want to call someone an idiot as your own personal statement then that's fine. This is what Jack should have done.

2) You should never ever use your position of power to insult someone, deserving or not. This is somewhat akin to your boss calling you an idiot in front of coworkers while on the job.

3) IMO Jack should apologize and probably get a warning but not get removed.


All in all Jack if you want to call someone an idiot have at it, just don't use your position to do it.

[Mato]

Jack ftw

[Nuto vixen]

Jack, you are poor excuse for a moderator and you have your job just because Smoosh is your best buddy. So stop accusing Tetris for pushing that issue just because AGA is his best friend.

I don't love AGA, he's abusive user, but the way you 'modded' him you proved you are no better than him.



Teal'auc

I happen to agree with this post 100% so I'm not going to bother repeating what quite a few have already said. I believe Jack was undeserving of the "promotion", and his constant lack of tact and judgement shows he is clearly unworthy of it also.

[TheRook]

2. It's just who I am. If you can't take it then tough. If you want to insult me back then feel free to do so, I wont stop you.

You're one of the few mods I still respect entirely mate so I'll ask you to spend 5 mins going to Jack's profile and viewing his posts over the course of his modship. You'll find this is not a once off occurance but a persistant thing that he's been allowed to get away with time and time again.

When critisism is brought up, what does he do? Tries to imply that I have anal sex with another forum poster. Does that sound like the behaviour that becomes a supermod?

IMHO that is completely and utterly unacceptable regardless of rank.

As far as your so called "criticism" it's more like a public hanging, drawing, and quartering, forgive me if I react like a typical human being in said circumstances.

2. No the point... and I have said this MANY times on the mod forum... that YOU SHOULDN'T INSULT PEOPLE ITS AGAINST THE RULES... just because you can ignore people insulting you doesnt mean you should have to put up with it and at the exact same time rule applies to them...

As a player I will stand up and say your not suitable for the position as a supermod... you went from ombudsmen to supermod... with no prior modding experience on these forums (this was all brought up in the mod forums) and I dont think you should have... you should have taken on modding an area first... even then it seems you dont take other peoples comments seriously...

You say that people are whinging when we try to put our points across and you show a severe lack of respect to most of the forum mods except those your buddy buddy with...

now as a Mod I dont want to work with you... your not suitable for the role your in and you are proving this time and time again in my eyes.

I will resign from my position as a mod of these forums within 2 weeks if something isn't done about your lack of respect to others.

So I'll say it again you are not suitable for a mod role and your posts/actions prove this...

TheRook

[Teal'auc of the Void]

Well said TheRook. But smooshable thinks he can do as he wants and guess what. He will rather lose a mod with decent insight, rather than his best buddy.

Smooshable, your double standards and favouritism make me want to puke. I seriously hope you'll be removed along with your underlings who do not care in which state these forums are, instead of you only going to care about your power trip!



Teal'auc

[TheRook]

I have voted and obviuosly from my post you can see I voted for his removal from the mod team.

I personally think in a situation like this it doesnt bode well for almost 50% to think that he should go...

a good mod should and one the forum users can trust I feel should have a much higher % of people thinking they are doing a good job... but thats just what I think.

I'm more than willing to put myself up for a vote to prove my point and If I get the same results as Jack I'll gladly step down.

TheRook

[Teal'auc of the Void]

I have voted and obviuosly from my post you can see I voted for his removal from the mod team.

I personally think in a situation like this it doesnt bode well for almost 50% to think that he should go...

a good mod should and one the forum users can trust I feel should have a much higher % of people thinking they are doing a good job... but thats just what I think.

I'm more than willing to put myself up for a vote to prove my point and If I get the same results as Jack I'll gladly step down.

TheRook

no need, mate. i've not seen you cross the line. And quite sure people will agree on this. I am sure if you did, you'd apologize and try to avoid it next time. while Jack just throws more and more excuses as to WHY his actions and behaviour are justified and all okay.

The mod team does not need to lose another decent mod - you.



Teal'auc

[dastupy]

I voted yes, why?
a) I'm pure biased and an asskisser of people who don't like you.... ( )
b) You are abusing the power you were giving , insulting people , calling people :"Severian is **Filtered** cause I said his posts are too long and made his bumbuddy look like an idiot." --> he called him gay..
And now let's look at the forum rules :
c. Abuse / Racism
Members of the SGW community are required to speak courteously to others. Personal attacks on members are not tolerated. This includes comments about one’s sex, gender, skin colour, religion or cultural heritage.

If AGA is warned for calling someone a "pedo" , than you should also be warned ....

@TheRook:
Sad to see you go
We all know how it is with Smoosh and Jack...

[Nimras]

I have voted and obviuosly from my post you can see I voted for his removal from the mod team.

I personally think in a situation like this it doesnt bode well for almost 50% to think that he should go...

a good mod should and one the forum users can trust I feel should have a much higher % of people thinking they are doing a good job... but thats just what I think.

I'm more than willing to put myself up for a vote to prove my point and If I get the same results as Jack I'll gladly step down.

TheRook

Lol M8 if i did that i would be out on my ass i know enough people want me gone under the claim i am biased and a bad mod hehe but actually could be fun to test if i am right .

But no matter Rock your a good mod i will not have you leave m8.