MGM vs Icke

Post Reply
agapooka
Semper Ubi Sub Ubi
Posts: 2607
Joined: Thu Mar 31, 2005 4:34 am
ID: 0

Honours and Awards

MGM vs Icke

The premises:

Case 1: Stargate: SG-1, where the Goa'ulds are depicted as a snake-form alien race, which enslaved earth's human population, posed as the gods of ancient religions and are capable of taking human hosts, thereby granting them the ability to appear in human form.

Case 2: David Icke, a British, new-age conspiracy theorist claims that a reptilian-like alien race enslaved earth's human population, posed as the gods of ancient religions and are capable of taking human form through genetic mutations and the drinking of human blood.

I would like to propose that the inherent similarities between the two cases would imply one of the following three links between them:

1. SG-1 was inspired by Icke's theories.
2. Icke was inspired by SG-1.
3. Both SG-1 and Icke are inspired by a third party, or multiple, directly or indirectly interconnected, third parties.

Alternatively, this could be the work of the scapegoat of the sceptic: coincidence; however, I believe that the reader will agree that it's much more fun to argue about the nature of the link binding the two cases than it is to establish whether or not there is one in the first place.

Agapooka
Agapooka wrote:The argument that because a premise cannot be proven false, it must be true, is known as a Negative Proof Fallacy in logic.
Mister Sandman wrote:Nothing at all near the negative proof fallacy in logic. If it cannot be proven false, it has to be true.
Pooka's UU Market Loyalty Card:

Rudy Pena: 1 stamp!

A Spider: 1 stamp!
User avatar
Jack
Evil Reincarnated
Posts: 13044
Joined: Sat Sep 02, 2006 8:42 pm
Alliance: The Empire
Race: Dragonborn
ID: 6475
Location: Whiterun

Re: MGM vs Icke

Clearly MGM was inspired by Icke's theories. Icke started his research in 1990, SG-1 did not air until 1997.

Case closed. =;
Ya'll acting like you know what monster is
Me have 25 years in the monster biz
All monsters think you can fuss with this
Well you can talk to me Snuffleupagus
Me sneak into your house, me leave before dawn
Your daughters will be pregnant and your cookies will be gone
Image
Malx wrote:Make kids not cancer!
agapooka
Semper Ubi Sub Ubi
Posts: 2607
Joined: Thu Mar 31, 2005 4:34 am
ID: 0

Honours and Awards

Re: MGM vs Icke

Nobody wants to discuss this? What a bunch of boring people we have here! Why, I'll go talk to the bugs crawling under moist rocks.

Mmmm. Moist rocks.
Agapooka wrote:The argument that because a premise cannot be proven false, it must be true, is known as a Negative Proof Fallacy in logic.
Mister Sandman wrote:Nothing at all near the negative proof fallacy in logic. If it cannot be proven false, it has to be true.
Pooka's UU Market Loyalty Card:

Rudy Pena: 1 stamp!

A Spider: 1 stamp!
Post Reply

Return to “General intelligent discussion topics”