Greatest player criterea...serious discussion

[Field Marshall]

What criteria in your opinion would constitute a player being one of the all time greats? I am not asking for your opinion about specific individuals..I am asking for a list, a formula of sorts devised..perhaps even with a rating system of 1-10 for points mentioned..let me give you an example of what I mean so as not to open the door for unnecessarry arguing..

1- impact on the game
2- leadership
3- longevity
4- influence..whether positive or negative
5- game change ability- did the player change or influence change of the game
6- politics
7- presence

etc..etc..etc...

All of the above are just examples, but you get the jist of my thoughts here. Enjoy.

8- Bravery
9- Honor
10- Loyalty

These are what I see as the most important parts of the game, that you can play with honor and take pride in everything you do. This is also what I would consider on choosing my allies.

Nice list JT, great idea

[Feri]

worbles through the thread >.>

[Aisar Saqib]

What criteria in your opinion would constitute a player being one of the all time greats? I am not asking for your opinion about specific individuals..I am asking for a list, a formula of sorts devised..perhaps even with a rating system of 1-10 for points mentioned..let me give you an example of what I mean so as not to open the door for unnecessarry arguing..

1- impact on the game
2- leadership
3- longevity
4- influence..whether positive or negative
5- game change ability- did the player change or influence change of the game
6- politics
7- presence

etc..etc..etc...

All of the above are just examples, but you get the jist of my thoughts here. Enjoy.

8- Bravery
9- Honor
10- Loyalty

These are what I see as the most important parts of the game, that you can play with honor and take pride in everything you do. This is also what I would consider on choosing my allies.

Nice list JT, great idea

I totally agree with you FM.... for me these 3 play vital role in building up a player character.... Every player should be loyal to his alliance and his fellow mates in times of war or other situations.... yeah a player should play with honor and pride....

and one thing i want to add... in this list bcz if player is in some alliance then he should have...

11. integrity... have moral principles...