Ashu wrote:Brdavs wrote:semirelated:
Is judas iscariot in heaven or in hell?
How can anyone know?
Well people are reasonably sure about saints... thats what saints are, people we here are certain are in heaven. and since popes declares them this they kinda have to be due to all that "hold on earth hold on heaven" thing hehe.
As far as Judas goes, it relates to someones sentiment that "suiciders are not forgiven" or something like that.
He betrayed jesus + commited suicide. But that was all "preordained" his free will can be questioned.
So if people that commit suicide dont get in, and if judas got stuck downstairs, simply cos he played his *vital* role in fathers plans, then I deduce that father is a bit of a douche isnt he?
If he is judged to be in heaven then cartian beliefs christians have are fundamentaly wrong (atleast those regarding suicide).