velya wrote:i think luna mentioned that her mother blew up infront of her, thats how she could see the thestrals (SP?)
that is correct, that tid-bit even made the movie that is recently out......
velya wrote:i think luna mentioned that her mother blew up infront of her, thats how she could see the thestrals (SP?)
i think luna mentioned that her mother blew up infront of her, thats how she could see the thestrals (SP?)
Informer wrote:not sure wheter this has already been pointed out as couldn't be bothered to read whole thread.
but there is a few flaws in the book.
mainly If Grindelwald had the Elder wand when he duelled Dumbledore why didn't he win? Its an unbeatable wand.
And if you say he wasn't the master of the wand - then dumbledore couldn't have been so neither would malfoy or harry.
Also about this trace - why didn't harry get a warning in the order of the pheonix when moody lupin and the rest broke into his house and used spells.
e.g tonks packed via magic.
answer that
lol
311 [TA] wrote:Informer wrote:not sure wheter this has already been pointed out as couldn't be bothered to read whole thread.
but there is a few flaws in the book.
mainly If Grindelwald had the Elder wand when he duelled Dumbledore why didn't he win? Its an unbeatable wand.
And if you say he wasn't the master of the wand - then dumbledore couldn't have been so neither would malfoy or harry.
Also about this trace - why didn't harry get a warning in the order of the pheonix when moody lupin and the rest broke into his house and used spells.
e.g tonks packed via magic.
answer that
lol
if you gave me the greatest pair of golf clubs ever
and gave tiger woods, a pair from walmart ........he would still beat me, and beat me badly ............
i know there is magic involved, but u have to know and understand how to use something ................
and could the duel have been fought with special protection spells in the arena that take away any advantage a wand may give
maybe they arent able to use their own wands
we dont know the cirumstances the duel was fought.........but im pretty sure since it was like a pay-per-view sorta thing or something where there were lots of rules and junk
anyway, im just saying u dont know the circumstances of the battle
so it would be possible for him to lose
just like voldermort was able to lose even when he has the wand etc.....he did beat himself but anyway u know
Informer wrote:Also about this trace - why didn't harry get a warning in the order of the pheonix when moody lupin and the rest broke into his house and used spells.
e.g tonks packed via magic.
answer that
lol
jreider014 wrote:Informer wrote:Also about this trace - why didn't harry get a warning in the order of the pheonix when moody lupin and the rest broke into his house and used spells.
e.g tonks packed via magic.
answer that
lol