Are Roman Catholics Christians?

User avatar
Juliette
Verified
The Queen
Posts: 31802
Joined: Sun Feb 06, 2005 6:57 pm
Race: Royalty
ID: 4323
Alternate name(s): Cersei Lannister
Location: Ultima Thule

Are Roman Catholics Christians?

Not according to www.chick.com.

In this delightful little story, Roman Catholicism is leveled as idolatry and false.
I urge you to understand that this is not my view, but it gives us food for thought.

Here's the link: http://www.chick.com/reading/tracts/0071/0071_01.asp


Would love to hear back from you after reading that little comic. :)
Image
User avatar
Legendary Apophis
Forum History
Posts: 13681
Joined: Tue Jun 14, 2005 12:54 pm
Alliance: Generations
Race: System Lord
ID: 7889
Alternate name(s): Apophis the Great
Location: Ha'TaK

Re: Are Roman Catholics Christians?

I'm curious to know what church they represent :-k ...I didn't read it completly, as the propaganda factor here reached the acceptable limit and it started to seriously annoy me. :lol:
Who the hell are they to pretend it's a false religion? :roll: ("we are the new ones in the place, the all knowing ones, all what was done before was wrong, because we say so, we are right, all others are wrong!" not really the best thing around)
This religion has been built up since the first council of Nicee in 325 led by Constantine, and even before, origins coming from Ist and IInd centuries where the basics were started. And I don't think they claimed it came all of a sudden completly built up without using references from other cults or religions. In North Africa they used local traditions within practicing of christianism in the beginnings. It's bt logical that it happens. When you claim it doesn't while it did, of course it's a problem.

Another one of those foolish movements who want to stick strictly to the Books and not 'adapt' from it.

To answer the question, of course they are. They are probably the oldest still remaining christian path around (by a matter of one or two hundred years). If they are false, then it's quite worrying for christianism and they should be careful before pretending that.
Image
Image
Spoiler

Incarnate - LG - LG1 - LG2 - LG3 - LG4 - AG - EAG ~ AGoL - Completed
Spoiler
<Dmonix> Damnit Jim how come every conversation with you always ends up discussing something deep and meaningful?
<Dmonix> We always end up discussing male/female differences or politics or football
<Dmonix> All the really important issues in life
Hitchkok
Forum Intermediate
Posts: 814
Joined: Tue Nov 10, 2009 10:25 am
ID: 0

Re: Are Roman Catholics Christians?

i just like the way they use out of context old testament qoutes to "prove" their points.
there is no useless knowledge, there is only knowledge we don't know how to use
math is the art of stating the obvious
Image
click the banner.
yay, i have bragging rights
teal'c wrote:Jesus maybe Hitch should be ombudsman he seems to be the only one with brains around here
GhostyGoo wrote:Capitalism is responsible for the death of humanity through a complete and utter destruction of ethical conduct, you DO know this, right?
Thanks to capitalism, when your doctor tells you you require a kidney transplant to survive, you no longer can be certain if you actually need a kidney transplant or your doctor simply needs a new speedboat. Nice.

-Goo
User avatar
Legendary Apophis
Forum History
Posts: 13681
Joined: Tue Jun 14, 2005 12:54 pm
Alliance: Generations
Race: System Lord
ID: 7889
Alternate name(s): Apophis the Great
Location: Ha'TaK

Re: Are Roman Catholics Christians?

Indeed...the part where they pretended Jesus would have said that Roman Catholic church is a *filtered* is one of things that turned me mad..yes it's just a comic but the bs reached critical limits.
Image
Image
Spoiler

Incarnate - LG - LG1 - LG2 - LG3 - LG4 - AG - EAG ~ AGoL - Completed
Spoiler
<Dmonix> Damnit Jim how come every conversation with you always ends up discussing something deep and meaningful?
<Dmonix> We always end up discussing male/female differences or politics or football
<Dmonix> All the really important issues in life
Hitchkok
Forum Intermediate
Posts: 814
Joined: Tue Nov 10, 2009 10:25 am
ID: 0

Re: Are Roman Catholics Christians?

the thing i don't get though, is what happened after repenting.
i mean, is it enough to just ask jesus once to save me, and i'm safe?
after all, if he died for all past and future human sins, i can sin all i want as long as i believe in JC?
there is no useless knowledge, there is only knowledge we don't know how to use
math is the art of stating the obvious
Image
click the banner.
yay, i have bragging rights
teal'c wrote:Jesus maybe Hitch should be ombudsman he seems to be the only one with brains around here
GhostyGoo wrote:Capitalism is responsible for the death of humanity through a complete and utter destruction of ethical conduct, you DO know this, right?
Thanks to capitalism, when your doctor tells you you require a kidney transplant to survive, you no longer can be certain if you actually need a kidney transplant or your doctor simply needs a new speedboat. Nice.

-Goo
thaltek
Spamity Spam In A Can
Posts: 20465
Joined: Sun Jun 25, 2006 6:19 pm
Location: chicago's nether region

Re: Are Roman Catholics Christians?

heriticks!!!!!
User avatar
Juliette
Verified
The Queen
Posts: 31802
Joined: Sun Feb 06, 2005 6:57 pm
Race: Royalty
ID: 4323
Alternate name(s): Cersei Lannister
Location: Ultima Thule

Re: Are Roman Catholics Christians?

hitchkok wrote:the thing i don't get though, is what happened after repenting.
i mean, is it enough to just ask jesus once to save me, and i'm safe?
after all, if he died for all past and future human sins, i can sin all i want as long as i believe in JC?

No no.. there's the rule that you have to tell people about Jesus. To do that, you'd have to at least have a semblance of a 'decent' life.

Just read this, and you will see how God will smite you if you don't.
http://www.chick.com/reading/tracts/0079/0079_01.asp
Image
thaltek
Spamity Spam In A Can
Posts: 20465
Joined: Sun Jun 25, 2006 6:19 pm
Location: chicago's nether region

Re: Are Roman Catholics Christians?

[-( hey leave jesus out of this... i mean cut the guy some slack, he works for minimum wage and works a 16 hour shift at tocobell....... so just leave the poor fellow alone....
Kit-Fox
Forum Elite
Posts: 1666
Joined: Wed Jun 28, 2006 5:22 am
Race: Tollan
ID: 0
Location: Nirvana

Re: Are Roman Catholics Christians?

Well you see the point is you can only go to hell if you know about it, this explains why it is important to shoot missionaries on sight ;) :P
The river tells no lies, yet standing at its shores the dishonest man still hears them

If you dont like what I post, then tough. Either dont read it or dont bother replying to it.
Hitchkok
Forum Intermediate
Posts: 814
Joined: Tue Nov 10, 2009 10:25 am
ID: 0

Re: Are Roman Catholics Christians?

Radiance wrote:
hitchkok wrote:the thing i don't get though, is what happened after repenting.
i mean, is it enough to just ask jesus once to save me, and i'm safe?
after all, if he died for all past and future human sins, i can sin all i want as long as i believe in JC?

No no.. there's the rule that you have to tell people about Jesus. To do that, you'd have to at least have a semblance of a 'decent' life.

Just read this, and you will see how God will smite you if you don't.
http://www.chick.com/reading/tracts/0079/0079_01.asp


OK, so the punishment for not accepting jesus is having to write bad poetry to all eternity?
but what i mean is this. nowhere does it say what happened to little nathan in those 40 years.
it just says he accepts Jesus, and that he went to heaven.

Kit-Fox wrote:Well you see the point is you can only go to hell if you know about it, this explains why it is important to shoot missionaries on sight ;) :P


i literally laughed out loud.
there is no useless knowledge, there is only knowledge we don't know how to use
math is the art of stating the obvious
Image
click the banner.
yay, i have bragging rights
teal'c wrote:Jesus maybe Hitch should be ombudsman he seems to be the only one with brains around here
GhostyGoo wrote:Capitalism is responsible for the death of humanity through a complete and utter destruction of ethical conduct, you DO know this, right?
Thanks to capitalism, when your doctor tells you you require a kidney transplant to survive, you no longer can be certain if you actually need a kidney transplant or your doctor simply needs a new speedboat. Nice.

-Goo
User avatar
Jack
Evil Reincarnated
Posts: 13044
Joined: Sat Sep 02, 2006 8:42 pm
Alliance: The Empire
Race: Dragonborn
ID: 6475
Location: Whiterun

Re: Are Roman Catholics Christians?

If Catholicism = Christianity then Judaism = Islam.
Ya'll acting like you know what monster is
Me have 25 years in the monster biz
All monsters think you can fuss with this
Well you can talk to me Snuffleupagus
Me sneak into your house, me leave before dawn
Your daughters will be pregnant and your cookies will be gone
Image
Malx wrote:Make kids not cancer!
User avatar
Legendary Apophis
Forum History
Posts: 13681
Joined: Tue Jun 14, 2005 12:54 pm
Alliance: Generations
Race: System Lord
ID: 7889
Alternate name(s): Apophis the Great
Location: Ha'TaK

Re: Are Roman Catholics Christians?

Dr. House wrote:If Catholicism = Christianity then Judaism = Islam.

Oh looks like we finally found someone who believed the propaganda.. :-"
Image
Image
Spoiler

Incarnate - LG - LG1 - LG2 - LG3 - LG4 - AG - EAG ~ AGoL - Completed
Spoiler
<Dmonix> Damnit Jim how come every conversation with you always ends up discussing something deep and meaningful?
<Dmonix> We always end up discussing male/female differences or politics or football
<Dmonix> All the really important issues in life
Kit-Fox
Forum Elite
Posts: 1666
Joined: Wed Jun 28, 2006 5:22 am
Race: Tollan
ID: 0
Location: Nirvana

Re: Are Roman Catholics Christians?

meh having finally bothered to look at the link in the first post I have to ask are any of you surprised?

I mean come on, pretty much every 'religion' of today has borrowed & subverted those that came before it or from those it had conquered so it should really be not all that shocking or surprising to find that there are lots of interpretations & contradictions. Especially so when considering the catholic church when you think to how it was created & formed into the 'one' church that it is today.
The river tells no lies, yet standing at its shores the dishonest man still hears them

If you dont like what I post, then tough. Either dont read it or dont bother replying to it.
User avatar
~[ Greased Gerbil ]~
Jack's Pet
Posts: 553
Joined: Thu Dec 18, 2008 5:51 pm
Alliance: Just tremble...
Race: Careless Fairy
ID: 555555555
Location: Look behind you

Re: Are Roman Catholics Christians?

Legendary Apophis wrote:This religion has been built up since the first council of Nicee in 325 led by Constantine, and even before, origins coming from Ist and IInd centuries where the basics were started.


Actually, every member of the Catholic clergy can be traced, by the laying of hands, directly back to Christ himself. Before the 4th century, the Church operated throughout the Roman Empire as an underground organisation, because Christianity would get your ass killed in those days.

I read about the first 3 or 4 frames of that rubbish, and I have 2 problems. The Vatican was not always a sovereign power. Catholics do not pledge an allegiance to the Vatican. On the contrary, the Church teaches us to honour and obey the just laws of our our nations. This silly cartoon implies that Catholics are all citizens of the Vatican, and that our national allegiances are divided. Not true. It's not like the Pope will declare war on my country, and test my loyalties. We are taught that His Holiness is infallible, but only in matters of faith and doctrine. He commands and leads a faith first, his position as head of state of the Vatican is a token position.

Secondly, I hate it when non-Catholics use the Bible to try to bring Catholics down. The Old Testament is a historical account of the faith of man. History will always have its inconsistencies, you must bear with what you read. The New Testament was written by men who either were or would later become Catholic Bishops (obviously under a different name, but I don't speak Hebrew or Aramaic). The Bible as we know it was compiled by the Catholic Church, from the writings that the Church considered to be most inspired by the Holy Spirit. Using it, and it alone, to govern Christianity is a concept we call Sola Scriptura (Bible Alone). We were taught that if every profound word and act of Christ were placed in the Bible, it would be too long for any man to read. There are things that the Church does, simply because they were a practice handed down to the Apostles, that were simply not written in a text included in the Bible.

</rant>
Image
User avatar
Legendary Apophis
Forum History
Posts: 13681
Joined: Tue Jun 14, 2005 12:54 pm
Alliance: Generations
Race: System Lord
ID: 7889
Alternate name(s): Apophis the Great
Location: Ha'TaK

Re: Are Roman Catholics Christians?

Why do you think they talk rubbish about Roman Catholics? ;)
As I said, it's oldest christian path still alive and it came around centuries before those movements, if not a millenium and centuries..not to mention patheticness of this kind of comment, throwing mud at the roots (roman catholics are the oldest still around christian movement) is one of silliest things I can think of.
Something that built up over centuries and is in the origin of other christian movements (they split from it remember? NOT the other way around), and some fools whose movement is one or few at max few centuries years old comes here and pretends that the oldest movement is false and not christian? Stop kidding me please! It's just making one look extremly silly to throw such bs. Whoever made this comic is a fool.
Image
Image
Spoiler

Incarnate - LG - LG1 - LG2 - LG3 - LG4 - AG - EAG ~ AGoL - Completed
Spoiler
<Dmonix> Damnit Jim how come every conversation with you always ends up discussing something deep and meaningful?
<Dmonix> We always end up discussing male/female differences or politics or football
<Dmonix> All the really important issues in life
Post Reply

Return to “General intelligent discussion topics”